It also seems that many movies were included on the list because of popular actors, directors, or combinations of the two that came together on a film. Great or popular talents do not necessarily make for a great movie. Look at Bringing Up Baby (1938) starring Katherine Hepburn and Cary Grant. Debacle. Baby is a leopard named Baby. [
Certainly the list is sprinkled with a few good movies; The Godfather (1972), Gone With the Wind (1939), the Graduate (1967), and Clockwork Orange (1971). But a mere sprinkling of good ones after building it up as ‘America’s 100 Greatest Movies’ left this guy feeling a bit punk about the whole thing.
As an exercise of mental remediation, I eventually set about compiling a list of 99
Good movies. My own list follows below.
Klem’s Top 99 Films
1 Fight Club - (1999) Brad Pitt, Ed Norton
2 Saving Private Ryan - (1998) Tom Hanks
3 Good, Bad, and the Ugly - (1966) Clint Eastwood
4 Gladiator - (2000) Russell Crowe
5 Heat - (1995) Al Pacino, Robert Deniro
6 Magnolia - (1999) Tom Cruise
7 Good Will Hunting - (1997) Matt Damon, Ben Affleck
8 Toy Story - (1995)
9 Seven - (1995) Brad Pitt, Morgan Freeman, Kevin Spacey
10 Ferris Bueller’s Day Off - (1986) Mathew Broderick
11-20
Rocky - (1976) Sylvester Stallone
the Big Lebowski - (1998) Jeff Bridges
Rocky II - (1979) Sylvester Stallone
Gattaca - (1997) Ethan Hawke, Uma Thurman
the Graduate - (1967) Dustin Hoffman
Jerry Maguire - (1996) Tom Cruise
the Godfather - (1972) Marlon Brando
Pulp Fiction - (1994) John Travolta, Uma Thurman
American Psycho - (2000) Christian Bale
the Prestige - (2006) Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman
21-30
the Shawshenk Redemption - (1994) Tim Robbins, Morgan Freeman
Toy Story II - (1999)
Bad Influence - (1990) Rob Lowe, James Spader
the Matador - (2005) Pierce Brosnan
Punch Drunk Love - (2002) Adam Sandler
Memento - (2000) Guy Pearce
Princess Bride - (1987) Cary Elwes
Mad Max - (1979) Mel Gibson
Star Wars - (1977) Harrison Ford
All Quiet On the Western Front - (1930)
31-40
Return of the Jedi - (1983) Harrison Ford
the Royal Tannenbaums - (2001) Gene Hackman, Owen Wilson
the Game - (1997) Michael Douglas
the World According To Garp - (1982) Robin Williams
the Freshman - (1990) Mathew Broderick, Marlon Brando
Clockwork Orange - (1971)
Boogie Nights - (1997) Mark Wahlberg
U-Turn - (1997) Sean Penn, Nick Nolte, Jennifer Lopez
Quest For Fire - (1981)
the Longest Day - (1962) John Wayne, Henry Fonda
41-50
True Romance - (1993) Christian Slater
Braveheart - (1995) Mel Gibson
Requiem For a Dream - (2000) Jared Leto, Jennifer Connelly
A Perfect World - (1993) Kevin Costner, Clint Eastwood
the Talented Mr. Ripley - (1999) Matt Damon, Jude Law
the Spanish Prisoner - (1997) Steve Martin
What Dreams May Come - (1998) Robin Williams
Catch 22 - (1970) Alan Arkin
Flatliners - (1990) Keifer Sutherland
Catch Me If You Can - (2002) Leonardo DiCaprio, Tom Hanks
51-60
Dead Man - (1995) Johnny Depp
the Silence of the Lambs - (1991) Jodie Foster, Anthony Hopkins
Twelve Monkeys - (1995) Bruce Willis, Brad Pitt
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid - (1969) Redford, Newman
the Dirty Dozen - (1967) Lee Marvin, Charles Bronson, E. Borgnine
the Truman Show - (1998) Jim Carey, Ed Harris
Raiders of the Lost Ark - (1981) Harrison Ford
the In-Laws - (1979) Alan Arkin, Peter Foulk
Dances with Wolves - (1990) Kevin Costner
Indecent Proposal - (1993) Demi Moore, Robert Redford
61-70
Kelly’s Heroes - (1970) Clint Eastwood
the Rules of Attraction - (2002) James Van Der Beek
She’s the One - (1996) Ed Burns
the Sixth Sense - (1999) Bruce Willis
Reservoir Dogs - (1992) Harvey Keitel, Michael Madsen, Tim Roth
My Own Private Idaho - (1991) Keanu Reeves, River Phoenix
Cast Away - (2000) Tom Hanks
Interview With the Vampire - (1994) Tom Cruise, Brad Pitt
the Big Red One - (1980) Lee Marvin
O Brother, Where Art Thou? - (2000) George Clooney
71-80
the Incredibles - (2004)
the Great Escape - (1963) Steve McQueen
the Pianist - (2002) Adrien Brody
Point Break - (1991) Keanu Reeves
A Midnight Clear - (1992)
the Swimmer - (1968) Burt Lancaster
Das Boot - (1981)
Six Degrees of Separation - (1993) Will Smith
Animal House - (1978) John Belushi
Lock, Stock, and Two Smoking Barrels - (1998)
81-90
Trainspotting - (1996)
Highlander - (1986) Christopher Lambert
Mutiny On the Bounty - (1935) Clark Gable
Rushmore - (1998) Bill Murray, Jason Schwartzman
Traffic - (2000) Benicio Del Toro, Michael Douglas
American Beauty - (1999) Kevin Spacey
the Train - (1964) Burt Lancaster
Snatch - (2000) Brad Pitt
the Terminator - (1984) Arnold Schwartzeneggar
Fast Times at Ridgemont High - (1982) Sean Penn
91-99
Patton - (1970) George C. Scott
the Beast - (1988 or 1989; about a tank in the Afghan desert)
Dirty, Rotten, Scoundrels - (1988) Steve Martin, Michael Caine
Papillon - (1973) Steve McQueen, Dustin Hoffman
Guess Who’s Coming To Dinner - (1967) Sidney Poitier, K. Hepburn
It’s a Wonderful Life - (1946) Jimmy Stewart
the Outsiders - (1983) Matt Dillon, Rob Lowe, Tom Cruise, K. Bacon
Pearl Harbor - (2001) Ben Affleck
the Wild Bunch - (1969) Ernest Borgnine, William Holden
Let me know if you feel I've neglected to mention a great one.
-klem